Audio books, sometimes the voice makes a difference
Does an audio rendition of a book enhance the experience or does it get in the way? I listen to audio books when I'm driving alone, which gives me half a dozen hours a week of listening pleasure. Today's selection might be OTR (old time radio shows) or a mystery book. My experience is that the reader’s effect ranges from selling the book to killing the book. I just closed an audio book half way into the first CD because of the reader’s voice and phrasing. I heard the words but I wasn’t getting the story! While the premise of the book (Creepers by David Morrell) interested me enough to pick up the audio at the library, I’m not encouraged to try the book.
Davina Porter, who reads the Hamish MacBeth series written by M.C. Beaton, has had the opposite effect. These books fall into the cozy classification, which is not my first choice in story type. The first book I heard from Porter hooked me on the series. Her accent and phrasing help me feel the Scottish Highland village of Lochdubh and it’s residents. She paints a great picture of Hamish, the lazy constable who , like a dog with a bone, won’t let go when he feels a wrong has been done. I just tried, for the second time to get into a printed Hamish book, and failed for the second time. Might well be my short attention span but for me Beaton’s book work better in audio than in print.
Nick Landrum gives voice to Jeff Lindsay’s Dexter books (two so far). Dexter is a sociopathic, serial killer sleuth. Pretty improbable premise, but Landrum’s rendition of Dexter is perfect! Dexter’s view of society and his place in it is so unique, almost a spoof of society and its members. The story is written first person, so we see the world through Dexter’s eyes and mind. This is a little like wearing the wrong glasses; you can see things, but everything is a little warped. Landrum makes you really want to know what Dex is going to say and do next. I’m sure I would enjoy reading Lindsay’s books, but Landrum’s presentation makes me desire more Dexter.
Have you heard any audio renditions of books that seem to take the author’s words to new levels?
quirky detective
Davina Porter, who reads the Hamish MacBeth series written by M.C. Beaton, has had the opposite effect. These books fall into the cozy classification, which is not my first choice in story type. The first book I heard from Porter hooked me on the series. Her accent and phrasing help me feel the Scottish Highland village of Lochdubh and it’s residents. She paints a great picture of Hamish, the lazy constable who , like a dog with a bone, won’t let go when he feels a wrong has been done. I just tried, for the second time to get into a printed Hamish book, and failed for the second time. Might well be my short attention span but for me Beaton’s book work better in audio than in print.
Nick Landrum gives voice to Jeff Lindsay’s Dexter books (two so far). Dexter is a sociopathic, serial killer sleuth. Pretty improbable premise, but Landrum’s rendition of Dexter is perfect! Dexter’s view of society and his place in it is so unique, almost a spoof of society and its members. The story is written first person, so we see the world through Dexter’s eyes and mind. This is a little like wearing the wrong glasses; you can see things, but everything is a little warped. Landrum makes you really want to know what Dex is going to say and do next. I’m sure I would enjoy reading Lindsay’s books, but Landrum’s presentation makes me desire more Dexter.
Have you heard any audio renditions of books that seem to take the author’s words to new levels?
quirky detective

